Art of the Qualified Plan Audit

In Summary A Warning Against Employer Discretion: “Bleeding-heart” plan sponsors are advised against approving non-safe harbor hardship distributions (like paying for weddings or maxed-out credit cards) on a case-by-case basis, as this discretionary approach risks discriminatory application and potential IRS penalties. The Plan Document Must Dictate Approvals: To remain compliant, any approved hardship reasons—especially non-safe … Continued

In Summary Defining Catch-Up Contributions Correctly: Catch-up contributions are specific amounts (e.g., $7,500 in 2024) that participants aged 50 and over can contribute only after they have first exceeded the standard elective deferral limit (e.g., $23,000 in 2024), a plan-imposed limit, or the ADP test limit. The Problem with Pro-Rata Payroll Coding: A common error … Continued

In Summary Keep in Mind: 403(b) eligibility and contribution rules (universal availability, OIAI, LTPT, post-severance contributions, ACP/ADP mechanics, and annual limits) determine who may defer and how much they — or the employer — can contribute. Auditors must verify the sponsoring organization’s tax-exempt status and obtain a valid, executed 403(b) plan document, including all necessary … Continued

In Summary SECURE 2.0 Expands Coverage: The SECURE 2.0 Act’s Long-Term Part-Time (LTPT) rules, effective for 403(b) plans as of January 1, 2023, require employers to permit employees to make elective deferrals if they work 500-999 hours annually for two consecutive years (starting with the 2023 plan year) and have reached age 21. Impact on … Continued

In Summary A Year of Service Is Negotiable, Not Literal: A “Year-of-Service” in retirement plans often does not equal 12 months, as employers can choose from various counting methods (Actual Hours, Elapsed Time, Equivalency) to define eligibility and vesting, essentially making a year “whatever the employer needs it to be.” Counting Methods: Different methods offer … Continued

In Summary Understanding and Reporting Late 401(k) Deposits: Late deposits of employee 401(k) contributions violate ERISA and are considered prohibited transactions; they must be reported on the Form 5500 (Schedule H for large plans, Line 10a for small plans filing 5500-SF). Two Paths to Correction Exist: Employers can rectify late deposits through self-correction, which requires … Continued

In Summary Differences in Distribution Reporting: There are inconsistencies between GAAP and Form 5500 instructions, particularly concerning benefit distributions. Form 5500, Schedule H includes benefits payable (approved but unpaid claims) as a liability, while accrual basis GAAP financial statements generally report distributions when paid, aligning with Forms 1099-R. Treatment of Corrective Distributions Varies: Accounting for … Continued

In Summary Accrual Basis Plan Compensation vs. Corporate Accounting: Accrual basis compensation for a retirement plan doesn’t necessarily align with the employer’s accrual basis compensation on corporate books, as many plans link the contribution obligation to the actual issuance of paychecks (which corresponds to W-2 wages received), rather than the dates the wages were earned. … Continued

In Summary Audit Threshold Change: There was a 2023 change to the Form 5500 participant count rule, which now excludes eligible participants who do not have an account balance on the first day of the plan year from the audit-triggering count. Timing Discrepancies: Various scenarios—including plan mergers, trade date vs. settlement date differences, and spinoffs—create … Continued

In Summary The 403(b) Audit Disclaimer’s Origin: The requirement for ERISA-covered 403(b) plans to have audited financial statements began in 2009, but due to a historical lack of employer involvement with older contracts, plan sponsors often could not locate all plan assets. This impossibility led to auditors issuing disclaimed opinions on the financial statements’ completeness. … Continued