Art of the Qualified Plan Audit

Do You Have a Template for a Request for Proposal (RFP) for a 401(k)/403(b) Plan? Almost every time I present an educational seminar, at least one attendee asks me if I have a template for a retirement plan audit RFP. After discussing the importance of selecting a quality plan auditor and providing a list of … Continued

This blog was updated 12.19.2025 with enhanced examples.  Background Effective January 1, 2026, catch-up eligible participants who are High Earners must make catch-up contributions on the Roth basis. The industry has been using the term Highly Paid Individuals, so we will use both terms for the sake of clarity and consistency with other published articles. … Continued

In Summary Applicability and Exemptions: Effective for plan years after December 31, 2024, new plans established after December 29, 2022, must implement automatic enrollment; however, exemptions apply to “grandfathered” pre-enactment plans, businesses with 10 or fewer employees, companies in business for less than three years, and governmental, church, or SIMPLE plans. Contribution and Escalation Mechanics: … Continued

In Summary Mandatory Roth Contributions for High Earners: Effective January 1, 2026, “High Earners” (defined as participants with prior-year FICA wages exceeding $150,000) are required to make all catch-up contributions—including the new “Super Catch-Up” for participants aged 60–63—on a Roth (after-tax) basis. Exclusions and Plan Limitations: The mandate strictly applies to employees with W-2 FICA … Continued

In Summary Common Errors and Overpayments: Due to the complexity of retirement plan rules, errors are common, resulting in excess amounts (operational failures). If these excess funds are distributed to a participant, it becomes an overpayment failure, which can stem from issues like inaccurate testing, incorrect vesting, or ineligible distributions. Correction Relief for Inadvertent Overpayments: … Continued

In Summary The 80-120 Rule for Audit Requirement: A retirement plan’s need for an annual audit is determined by counting participants with account balances on the first day of the plan year. The 80-120 rule is an exception that allows a plan with 80 to 120 participants to file as a small plan (no audit) … Continued

In Summary Risk of Tainted Assets: Directly merging plan assets preserves their source classification, creating a risk that previous qualification errors in the merged plan (resulting in “tainted assets”) could affect the audited financial statements of the successor plan. Rollovers Eliminate Risk: The optimal way to avoid tainted assets is by having participants conduct rollovers … Continued

In Summary Final Form 5500 Filing, Asset Distribution, and Legal Title: A plan’s final Form 5500 filing obligation is triggered not by the effective date of termination, but by the complete distribution of all assets. In a merger, the final filing is determined by the date the legal title of the assets transfers to the … Continued

In Summary The New Program: There is a new Self-Correction Component (SCC) of the Voluntary Fiduciary Correction Program (VFCP), which allows plan sponsors to officially use the DOL’s online calculator for self-correction. This new option is only available for specific errors, such as delinquent contributions deposited within 180 days where the associated lost earnings are … Continued

In Summary Unclear Deadlines for 401(k) Deferrals: The Department of Labor (DOL) regulations for 401(k) deferral deposits are unclear, using “earliest” and “reasonably” rather than a firm deadline. While small plans (under 100 accounts) have a 7-day safe harbor, large plans do not. As a result, many large plans adopt a 3-day industry standard, which … Continued